There has been a recent brouhaha over the fact that the new federal healthcare law (Obama-care) mandates that all insurance companies cover the cost of birth control pills. The spin here is that Republican candidates are now decrying this intrusion of religious freedom because even churches will be required to offer employee insurance plans provide this benefit.
So Catholic Churches, an organization that opposes (read: forbids) the use of contraception in any form, will be required to provide birth control pills to their employees at no cost. This is a callous and irresponsible intrusion of the federal government into matters (religious) that they have no business legislating. A speaker at the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) thought that anyone advocating this reckless exercise in federal authority should have had parents who used contraception (so that they wouldn’t exist to spread their filthy wrong-headed ideas).
Rick Santorum is even on the record as saying that all contraception is wrong and that, if he is elected president, he will work to outlaw all forms of birth control. see the video
And that’s all good and that’s how Fox News and the GOP are slanting it now. Obama and Obama-care are trying to shove their liberal/gay agenda down the throats of churches and they are evil and wrong.
Unfortunately for them, that whole argument is total crap because the internet exists to do some research.
First off, how much hypocrisy are we dealing with when catholic bishops start screaming about this issue? Quite a lot, even their own parishioners do not listen to this crap. Percentage of American women who use birth control: 98% Percentage of Catholic American women who use birth control: 98% (98% of women who have sex)
Is this a federal problem? Not really, 28 states currently have laws on the books that already make this a mandatory health insurance benefit. Those state laws were challenged many times but they were repeatedly found to be constitutional and all of them stood up in court. Several of them (8 states) actually require churches to offer this benefit. The federal law exempts churches, but does not exempt church-operated entities like hospitals and schools.
The fact is, this isn’t an overreach of federal authority. Contraception is important because people are going to have sex. Even married people have sex without trying to make more babies, because it is fun. And people who say this is wrong just SAY it is wrong, they still do it.
So, understand that the GOP argument that this is all another instance of Obama trying to take all your rights away, is bullshit. And if this is bullshit, how much of the other stuff coming out of their mouths can you trust?
This site is helpful: http://www.politifact.com/
